Medicare PPS is arguably the best payer for at least 98% of all Medicare-certified home health agencies. Yet many agencies struggle to produce strong financial results under that payment system. Why?
Favorable reimbursement alone does not make an agency successful. It must be coupled with an agency becoming clinically effective, cost-effective, operationally effective, and cost-efficient. What agencies do—and especially what they fail to do—directly affects their ability to achieve those results. Those results should be goals for every Medicare-certified home health agency.
Do you have those identified as agency goals?
Payment reductions and other external pressures deserve attention. So do the agency’s decisions, omissions, and management practices. When leadership consistently attributes disappointing results to outside forces without examining its own responsibilities and actions (or lack thereof), problems that could be addressed persist—and often worsen.
Before examining those responsibilities, we need a reference point for evaluating financial performance. For this discussion, MedPAC’s reported industry-average Medicare margin provides that dividing line: we will identify agencies generating Medicare margins at and above that percentage as above-average financial performers; those generating margins below it as below-average financial performers.
Keep in mind that the MedPAC Medicare Margin % equates to an industry average. So, to relate that to school grades, that would equate to a C, on the A to F grading scale. Agencies that score below average would need to improve just to reach average, and the further you are below that Medicare Margin %, the more work would be required. However, in this era of reimbursement, and all that is transpiring, are you really going to be satisfied with just being average?
Note: these comparisons address financial outcomes, separate from clinical performance and quality outcomes.
Within the group meeting or exceeding that average, there are additional tiers of performance:
- Adequate performers: Medicare margins equal to MedPAC’s reported margin through 20% above it.
- High performers: Medicare margins more than 20% through 75% above MedPAC’s reported margin.
- Top performers: Medicare margins more than 75% above MedPAC’s reported margin.
Where does your agency fall—and does its leadership understand why?
Clinical issues can certainly contribute to an agency’s struggles. Inaccurate assessments, poor alignment between identified patient needs and the Plan of Care, and ineffective care coordination can affect both patient care and financial results. Those issues warrant attention, but this article focuses on the nonclinical financial and operational responsibilities that agencies too often neglect.
Throughout PPS, agencies have used Medicare profits to subsidize their non-Medicare business, whether they recognized that or not. That makes it essential to understand and manage Medicare performance. Weaknesses in that performance can threaten the organization’s financial stability.
The following ten areas deserve particular scrutiny. Each represents a management responsibility. Failing to address any of them can undermine an agency’s effectiveness, efficiency, and financial performance. Failing to utilize any of them can make trying to make you agency effective and financially efficient feel like a Sisyphean task. The ten areas I am focusing on are:
- Budgeting
- Forecasting
- Monthly Financial-Operational Analyses
- Annual PPS Payment Change Analyses
- Resource Utilization Reviews
- LUPAs & Outliers
- Patient Encounter Analyses—Proactive & Reactive
- Staffing & Productivity
- Reasonable Compensation Reviews
- Employee Benefits & Profit Sharing
For each, the question is straightforward: What is your agency doing—or failing to do—and how is that affecting its results?
1. Budgeting
A budget should establish how an agency intends to operate and the financial results it expects those operations to produce. Without one, what is management using to determine whether its plans are financially workable?
Too many agencies either operate without a budget or prepare one by adding a percentage to the prior year’s revenue and expenses. Either approach can carry existing inefficiencies into the next year without ever identifying or questioning them. A budget that simply perpetuates poor performance does little to help an agency improve.
To the extent possible, build a strong home health budget around the drivers of the agency’s revenues and expenses. Patient volume, payer mix, and anticipated reimbursement drive revenue. Visit utilization by discipline, staffing arrangements, productivity, compensation, benefits, and overhead requirements drive expenses. Understanding those relationships lets management evaluate how operational changes will affect financial results. This is the beginning of operational understanding.
Those assumptions must work together. Projecting census growth without considering the resources needed to serve those patients—or increasing compensation without evaluating its effect on costs and margins—does not establish a workable operating plan.
The budgeting process should force management to examine how the agency operates, identify where change is needed, and establish measurable expectations, and then measure actual results against budgeted expectations. If the projected results are inadequate, management should address the underlying assumptions and operating practices before accepting those results as the agency’s plan.
Without that process, agencies leave too much of their financial performance to chance and miss opportunities to identify and address problems before they occur.
A well-developed, driver-based budget also provides the foundation for a Forecaster, allowing management to update anticipated results as those drivers change—the subject of our next section.
2. Forecasting
A budget establishes the agency’s operating plan, but conditions rarely remain exactly as anticipated. Patient volume changes, payer mix shifts, employees leave, compensation increases, and visit utilization fluctuates. Does management understand what those changes mean for the agency’s anticipated financial results?
A Forecaster is the agency’s living budget. As each month is closed, actual results replace the projections for that month, incorporating year-to-date financial and operational performance. The remaining months continue to reflect budget projections based on the underlying drivers and assumptions. Management can then revise those assumptions in the Forecaster to more accurately project likely year-end results based on what it knows at the time.
Updating the underlying drivers—not simply adjusting a revenue or expense total—helps reveal the operational and financial consequences of changing conditions. A census increase, for example, may produce additional revenue, but its contribution to profitability depends on the payer mix, reimbursement, utilization, and staffing costs associated with those patients.
Forecasting also allows management to evaluate potential decisions before committing to them. What happens if the agency hires another clinician, increases compensation, expands its service area, or accepts additional patients under a particular payer contract? How much additional volume or productivity improvement would be needed to support those decisions?
As actual results accumulate and assumptions are updated, management can assess where the agency is headed, whether corrective action is needed, and how proposed changes could affect the outcome. Understanding increases.
Without forecasting, leadership may recognize that results have fallen short but still lack an understanding of what those results imply for the months ahead. That delay slows response time and can turn manageable problems into much harder ones to deal with.
A budget provides the starting point. Forecasting makes that planning process ongoing, giving management an opportunity to influence future results while there is still time to change them.
3. Monthly Financial-Operational Analyses
Producing monthly financial statements does not mean an agency understands its performance. Financials tell part of the story, but they cannot fully explain the operational activities and decisions that produced those results.
A meaningful monthly Financial-Operational Analysis brings together information that too often remains siloed in accounting, clinical, scheduling, payroll, and billing systems. By connecting revenue, expenses, and margins with patient volume, payer mix, reimbursement, visits by discipline, staffing, productivity, and costs per visit, it reveals relationships that separate reports cannot adequately explain. The value comes from turning that combined information into a more complete understanding of the agency’s performance—and what management can do to improve it.
These reviews also enable monthly budget-to-actual analyses. Comparing actual results with the budget’s underlying drivers and assumptions helps management identify where performance departed from the plan and understand why. Comparisons with prior periods and meaningful performance benchmarks provide additional context.
For example, payroll exceeding budget means little on its own. Did patient volume exceed expectations? Were more visits provided? Did compensation rates rise, overtime increase, or productivity decline? Each explanation has different implications and may require a different response. Likewise, revenue growth does not establish improved financial performance if the cost of producing that revenue increased even faster.
The analysis must also look beyond agency-wide totals. Combined results can conceal weaknesses within individual locations, disciplines, or payer contracts. Billing delays, denials, and collection problems deserve attention when reported profitability is failing to translate into cash.
These reviews must be timely and followed by action. Identifying a deteriorating trend months after it began allows its financial consequences to accumulate. Identifying the same problem every month without assigning responsibility and following through accomplishes little.
Management should finish each review understanding what happened, why it happened, what needs to change, who is responsible, and when progress will be evaluated. Those findings should also inform the Forecaster. Otherwise, the agency is producing reports while leaving the management work undone.
4. Annual PPS Payment Change Analyses
Each year, agencies hear a national percentage describing the projected change in Medicare home health spending. Agencies often treat that percentage as though it represents the projected change in their payment rates. Many that talk about the Proposed and Final Rules imply, or even say that will be the change in an agency’s PPS payment rates. For most HHAs, it is not, and never has been in the 26+ years of PPS, so why would anyone say that, let alone think that?
The spending projection indicates the direction payment rate changes will generally tend to follow, but individual results vary. Some payment rate changes will be more favorable, some less favorable, and some may even move in the opposite direction. Across more than 650 CBSAs and service areas, payment rate changes will differ in practically every one of them.
Applying the headline percentage to the prior year’s Medicare revenue does not establish what an agency should expect. Changes in payment rates, wage indices, case-mix weights, LUPA thresholds, and other payment components interact with the agency’s service areas and patient population. The resulting impact can differ substantially from the national figure—and even vary across locations within the same organization. In fact, two agencies, serving the same Service Area(s) can realize significantly different impacts to their Medicare revenues under the same rule.
A meaningful PPS Payment Change Analysis determines how those changes will affect the agency’s own Medicare reimbursement. It should give management an understanding of the overall impact and identify important differences among service areas, locations, and patient groups that an agency-wide percentage can conceal.
The analysis should then consider costs. A reimbursement increase does not necessarily improve margins if compensation, benefits, supplies, and other expenses rise faster. Conversely, a payment reduction makes understanding the agency’s costs and opportunities for operational improvement even more consequential.
Analyzing the Proposed Rule gives management time to evaluate potential effects and prepare. Updating that analysis for the Final Rule provides the basis for incorporating the adopted changes into the agency’s budget and Forecaster. It also gives the agency its last opportunity before the new payment year begins to project the expected impact on its Medicare revenue for the upcoming year.
Without an agency-specific analysis, management is planning around an industry headline rather than understanding its own reimbursement outlook. Waiting until payments arrive to discover the impact sacrifices time that could have been used to prepare.
5. Resource Utilization Reviews
An agency can know what it pays for its resources without understanding how effectively it uses them. Employee compensation, contractor rates, and medical supply prices tell only part of the story. Decisions about their use can create substantial costs that remain hidden within otherwise familiar expense totals.
A Resource Utilization Review examines whether the agency’s use of employees, contractors, visits, and medical supplies supports clinically appropriate, cost-effective services. Arrangements that once made sense can become expensive as patient volume, service areas, staffing availability, and patient needs change. When did your agency last question whether its current approach still makes sense?
Hidden utilization costs matter because they often look like ordinary costs of doing business. An unnecessary visit, an avoidable scheduling gap, excessive travel, or supplies used without sufficient attention to need and cost may attract little notice individually. Repeated across patients, clinicians, and locations, their cumulative financial effect can be substantial.
The mix of resources also matters. A lower rate does not automatically reduce total cost, and a higher rate does not automatically make a resource less cost-effective. Employee-versus-contractor decisions and visit utilization by discipline deserve more scrutiny than a comparison of individual rates or costs per visit can provide.
These reviews should challenge established habits. “That is how we have always done it” offers no assurance that an agency uses resources appropriately, effectively, or efficiently.
If your agency has never conducted a focused Resource Utilization Review—or hasn’t done so in several years—how much of its current cost structure reflects deliberate decisions, and how much reflects practices that have simply gone unquestioned?
6. LUPAs & Outliers
Most agencies know their LUPA percentage and whether they receive outlier payments. But knowing those figures doesn’t mean management understands what is driving them—or their effect on financial performance.
LUPAs deserve more attention than a monthly count or percentage. What portion reflects circumstances the agency could reasonably avoid? Are recurring scheduling, coordination, or follow-through problems contributing to lost revenue? Lost revenue, the difference between the LUPA revenue received and the full 30-day payment rate is significant. An agency that tracks its LUPAs without examining the reasons behind them can repeatedly experience the same avoidable financial consequences.
The financial effect also depends on the encounters involved. Two agencies with the same LUPA percentage can experience materially different revenue consequences. An acceptable-looking agency-wide percentage may also conceal recurring problems within particular locations or patient groups.
Outlier payments warrant similar scrutiny. Additional reimbursement can look favorable, but what does it reveal about the resources those encounters consume? Does management understand whether those payments adequately offset the associated costs, or whether recurring utilization patterns are undermining the agency’s results?
An agency can become accustomed to outlier payments without questioning the operational circumstances that produce them. That familiarity can let costly practices persist, especially when management focuses on the added revenue without understanding the underlying financial impact.
LUPAs and outliers should be examined as indicators of how patient needs, care delivery, utilization, and reimbursement interact. If your agency knows the percentages and payment totals but cannot explain the causes and financial consequences, it has information but still lacks the understanding needed to manage performance.
7. Patient Encounter Analyses—Proactive & Reactive
An agency’s Medicare financial performance results from individual patient encounters. Yet how many agencies evaluate the anticipated financial result of those encounters before providing services—examine what actually happened afterward—and then compare the two?
A proactive Patient Encounter Analysis connects the patient needs identified through OASIS with the Plan of Care, projected visit utilization, anticipated reimbursement, and agency-specific costs. It gives management and clinical leadership a chance to understand the implications of planned services while there is still time to question assumptions and address concerns.
IFS4hh’s Case-Mix Planner™ (CMP) was developed to support this proactive evaluation, helping agencies understand how planned services, anticipated reimbursement, agency-specific costs, and projected financial results relate before those services are delivered. Increasing understanding.
The strength of the correlation between OASIS and the Plan of Care matters. An agency can accurately identify patient needs and still develop a care plan that doesn’t reflect them. Without examining that connection, unnecessary utilization and its associated costs can become embedded in the care plan before the first scheduled visits occur.
Reactive analysis completes the picture by examining actual encounter results. Did services unfold as anticipated? Were visits added, missed, or shifted among disciplines? Did actual costs and reimbursement produce the expected financial outcome? Recurring differences can reveal planning, coordination, or execution weaknesses that agency-wide averages conceal. Increasing understanding even more.
Used together, proactive and reactive analyses create an opportunity to learn from completed encounters and improve future planning. Without that connection, the same poorly understood approach can be repeated across similar patients, multiplying its financial consequences.
If your agency waits until the monthly financial statements arrive to discover that Medicare performance has deteriorated, how many opportunities to understand and influence those results have already passed?
8. Staffing & Productivity
Staffing decisions establish a substantial portion of an agency’s cost structure. Yet agencies often hire in response to immediate pressure without adequately evaluating how those decisions will affect capacity, productivity, and financial performance.
Being busy does not necessarily mean an agency is understaffed. Scheduling inefficiencies, excessive travel, uneven workloads, documentation backlogs, and poorly defined responsibilities are but a few of the inefficiencies that can consume staff time while limiting productive capacity. Adding employees without understanding those conditions can increase expenses while leaving the underlying problems unresolved.
Agencies need meaningful productivity expectations that reflect the work being performed. A visit count alone cannot fully explain an employee’s workload or contribution. Visit types, patient needs, geography, documentation, and other assigned responsibilities affect what staff can reasonably accomplish. Expectations that ignore those differences can conceal inefficiencies, create uneven demands, and undermine accountability.
The same scrutiny should extend to administrative and supervisory staffing. As patient volume and operations change, does the agency reassess its support structure, or do positions and responsibilities simply accumulate? Declining volume can leave an agency supporting a staffing structure its current business can no longer sustain.
Management should understand its existing capacity before deciding that growth requires additional personnel. It should also recognize when insufficient staffing or unproductive staff utilization creates overtime, costly dependence on contractors, employee turnover, or missed opportunities to serve patients.
Effective staffing and productivity management requires clear expectations, an understanding of how employees spend their time, and follow-through when results fall short. If leadership cannot explain the relationship between staffing, workload, productive capacity, and costs, how can it know whether its next hiring decision will improve performance or make an existing problem more expensive?
9. Reasonable Compensation Reviews
Compensation is one of an agency’s largest financial commitments. Yet how often does management evaluate whether compensation remains reasonable for the responsibilities performed, the agency’s size and complexity, and the results being achieved?
A Reasonable Compensation Review should consider the full compensation arrangement, including salary, bonuses, benefits, and other forms of remuneration. Reviewing a salary alone can leave management with an incomplete understanding of what a position actually costs.
Market comparisons provide useful context, but a job title alone does not establish comparability. Two individuals with the same title may have substantially different responsibilities, authority, workloads, and organizational demands. Compensation decisions should reflect those differences rather than rely on a convenient salary figure from an organization that bears little resemblance to the agency.
Owner, executive, and related-party compensation deserve the same scrutiny. Longstanding arrangements can become accepted expenses without anyone revisiting whether they remain appropriate as the organization changes. When leadership asks employees to improve productivity or control costs, its own compensation decisions should withstand examination as well.
Reasonableness also does not automatically establish affordability. An agency may offer compensation consistent with its market while maintaining an operating structure that cannot support the total expense. That disconnect requires management to examine the relationship between compensation, staffing, responsibilities, productivity, and revenue.
These reviews can identify compensation that is excessive, insufficient, or misaligned with the expected work. Each can create financial and operational consequences, from unnecessary expense to turnover and difficulty attracting capable employees.
If your agency has never objectively reviewed its compensation arrangements, what supports the conclusion that they are reasonable—and that the agency is receiving appropriate value for what it pays?
10. Employee Benefits & Profit Sharing
Employee benefits represent another substantial investment in an agency’s workforce. Does management understand the overall cost of that investment, whether it is reasonable, and how effectively it supports recruitment, retention, and organizational performance?
Benefits can accumulate over time through individual decisions, renewals, and longstanding practices without a comprehensive review of the total package. An agency may closely scrutinize wage increases while giving far less attention to the combined cost of insurance, paid time off, retirement contributions, and other benefits. Those costs belong in the agency’s assessment of total compensation and financial sustainability.
Cost is only part of the question. Does the agency offer benefits employees value, understand, and consider meaningful reasons to stay? A costly package that employees neither understand nor appreciate may produce little of the retention value management assumes it provides.
Is the agency using employee profit sharing and a 401(k) or 403(b), as applicable, as part of its benefits and retention program? Has management evaluated whether those arrangements could strengthen the overall compensation package and give employees an opportunity to share in the organization’s success?
Profit sharing also creates an opportunity to connect employee interests with agency performance. That connection becomes more meaningful when employees understand how their work contributes to clinical effectiveness, operational efficiency, cost control, and sustainable profitability. Simply announcing a financial reward does little to build that understanding.
These programs deserve deliberate evaluation alongside the agency’s other financial commitments. Management should evaluate what these programs cost, whether the agency can afford them, how employees value them, and whether they contribute to retention.
If your agency views benefits only as an expense to renew each year, what opportunities is it missing to use that investment more effectively—for both its employees and the organization?
What Is Your Agency Doing About Its Results?
Medicare PPS does not relieve agency leadership of the responsibility to manage effectively. Neither do payment reductions, staffing challenges, or unfavorable payer contracts. Those pressures make it even more important to understand and address the factors management can control.
The ten areas discussed here are interconnected. Budgeting establishes expectations. Forecasting updates expectations. Monthly Financial-Operational Analyses explain results and increase understanding. The remaining reviews examine decisions and practices that shape those results. Neglecting any of them can weaken the agency’s ability to become clinically effective, cost-effective, operationally effective, and cost-efficient. Neglecting all of them poorly positions an agency for success and creates self-inflicted pressure points that will challenge the agency as long as all those areas are ignored by management (a Sisyphean issue).
An agency does not have to be losing money to have substantial room for improvement. Profitability does not mean resources are used effectively, hidden costs are understood, or the organization is achieving the financial results it could reasonably produce. Even above-average performers should question what their current results may conceal.
Leadership must be willing to examine its own contribution to the outcome. Which of these responsibilities receive consistent attention at your agency? Which have been postponed, addressed superficially, or never undertaken? What has that inaction cost—and what will it continue to cost?
IFS4hh specializes in helping home health agencies address these areas and more. Our work connects financial and operational information, turns that information into understanding, and helps leadership use that understanding to improve decisions, strengthen accountability, and run more effective, efficient operations.
If this article has identified areas your agency has never examined—or questions your current reports cannot answer—contact IFS4hh to discuss where a focused review could help. You do not need to wait for a financial crisis to seek an outside perspective.
You cannot control every pressure facing your agency. But you can control what you do—or do not do—in response.


0 Comments